No Movement on Death Sentence for Afghan Internet User

Sayed Parwez Kambakhsh is a journalism student at Balk University in Mazar-i Sharif. He supposedly copied text from an Iranian website criticizing Islam's stance on the treatment of women, and added his own thoughts on the matter—much like a blogger would. For this, the Afghan intelligence services investigated him, and after his arrest a court in Balkh province convicted him of heresy and sentenced him to death.

At his most recent appeals hearing, according to Jean MacKenzie at IWPR, Kambakhsh was berated by his own judge:

Presiding judge Abdul Salam Qazizada has weathered several Afghan administrations. He is a holdover from the Taleban regime, and his antagonism to the defendant was visible…

During the session, Qazizada appeared to take on the role of prosecutor rather than impartial judge, engaging in a legal duel with defence attorney Mohammad Afzal Nooristani. Lacking a gavel, he repeatedly banged his pen against his microphone in an effort to halt Nooristani’s defence of his client.

Time and again the judge attacked Kambakhsh, who sat pale but composed in the defendant’s chair.

“Just tell me why you did these things,” insisted Qazizada. “What were your motives?”

“I cannot give you reasons, since I did not do anything,” responded Kambakhsh.

Kambakhsh is alleged to have been beaten since his initial imprisonment last December, however given the length of time it took for an examination to be scheduled, most of the physical markings have healed over. Though he plead guilty, he claims to have done so under duress.

Kambakhsh also stands accused of moral character flaws such as asking too many questions in class, seeking attention and popularity, being impolite, and swapping dirty jokes over his cellphone.

Kambakhsh faces many obstacles: his defense lawyers hadn't examined his case file even a week before his first appeals hearing, and the Upper House of Parliament has voiced its support for his execution, along with conservative clerics and some tribal elders.

In 2006, Abdul Rahman was sentenced to death for converting to Christianity. His life was spared when, under intense international pressure, he was declared legally insane and deported to Italy. Similar international pressure is not as readily apparent in Kambakhsh's case: a story on his case in the international media has not appeared for months, despite worrying indications this is a revenge case for his brother's work with IWPR.

See heartbreaking images of Afghan policemen escorting Sayed Parwez Kambakhsh after a court hearing in Kabul on May 18, 2008 at the dailylife website.

7 comments

  • Jean MacKenzie

    thanks for changing the headline; however, your comment about international pressure is not exactly accurate. It is true that there has been less coverage in the U.S. than in Europe, but there have been pieces (see mine on Washington Post Online. the case has also figured prominently in high-level meetings with international leaders, such as condoleezza rice and david miliband. the difference with Abdul rahman is that his case only lasted for a few weeks; parwez has been in prison for nine months. Abdul rahman was not deported, he was allowed to leave.
    Thanks for doing this, but please check your facts a bit more.

  • Jean MacKenzie

    also, you may want to change the photo — there are lots of others of parwez as he looks now.

  • Ms. MacKenzie,

    Allow me the indulgence of responding. I said the story hadn’t received attention in the international media for months — the most recent news stories I could find were all dated in January, just after his arrest and initial trial. Your piece took some digging to find on Post Global, which was, I am sorry to say, not very easy to find. It’s tough to accuse me of negligent research when I have to use your name in a search engine to find a piece about Kambakhsh.

    As for Rahman, the way his plight was portrayed, again in most media accounts (including other news roundups), is that after he was declared insane the Afghan and U.S. governments coordinated to find him a safe haven where he could live in peace; Italy very kindly offered him refuge. While it may have not been official deportation, it certainly looked like deportation. If you are uncomfortable with calling a spade a spade when it is not officially a spade, then I can ask my editors to to modify this post.

    I really do appreciate your comments here — you’re right the headline was incorrect, as I had misread your story. I regret that. But I don’t think I’m being as sloppy with my facts as you’re making me out to be.

    -Joshua Foust

  • [...] Kambakhsh’s case was covered previously by both Global Voices and Global Voices Advocacy. [...]


  • [...] case was covered previously by both Global Voices and Global Voices Advocacy. Posted by Joshua Foust  Print Version Share [...]


  • [...] كلّ من الأصوات العالمية وقسم الدفاع عن الشبكة التابع لموقع أصوات عالمية قضية كامباخش [...]


  • [...] پرونده‌ی کامبخش در دو بخش Global Voices و Global Voices Advocacy پوشش داده شده [...]


Join the conversation

Authors, please log in »

Guidelines

  • All comments are reviewed by a moderator. Do not submit your comment more than once or it may be identified as spam.
  • Please treat others with respect. Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.